Player Ratings Pro
Home › Teams › Indianapolis Colts

Indianapolis Colts all-time Madden ratings

2006–2027 · 695 players · 1,480 rated seasons

Highest rated ever99
Players695
Editions22
97+ seasons17

All-time depth chart

SlotPlayerPosEditionOVR
QB Peyton Manning QBMadden NFL 0699
RB Edgerrin James HBMadden NFL 0696
FB Stanley Havili FBMadden NFL 1580
WR Marvin Harrison WRMadden NFL 0698
TE Dallas Clark TEMadden NFL 1196
LT Tarik Glenn LTMadden NFL 0896
LG Quenton Nelson LGMadden NFL 2295
C Jeff Saturday CMadden NFL 0796
RG Jake Scott RGMadden NFL 0885
RT Ryan Diem RTMadden NFL 0993
EDGE Dwight Freeney REMadden NFL 0698
DT Corey Simon DTMadden NFL 0792
LB Robert Mathis ROLBMadden NFL 1593
CB Vontae Davis CBMadden NFL 1695
S Bob Sanders SSMadden NFL 0999
K Adam Vinatieri KMadden NFL 0898
P Pat McAfee PMadden NFL 1695

Highest-rated Colts, every edition

EditionsPlayerPosBest OVR
2006–2008 Peyton Manning QB99
2009 Bob Sanders SS99
2010–2012 Peyton Manning QB99
2013 Antoine Bethea FS91
2014 Pat McAfee P94
2015 Robert Mathis ROLB93
2016 Pat McAfee P95
2017 Vontae Davis CB91
2018 Andrew Luck QB90
2019 Jabaal Sheard RE89
2020 Andrew Luck QB92
2021–2022 Quenton Nelson LG95
2023 Jonathan Taylor HB95
2024–2026 Quenton Nelson LG92
2027 Jonathan Taylor HB96

Players rated 90+, by edition

0 5 10 15 Madden 2006: 8 rated 90+, 17 rated 85+ 8 Madden 2007: 11 rated 90+, 17 rated 85+ 11 Madden 2008: 9 rated 90+, 18 rated 85+ 9 Madden 2009: 14 rated 90+, 20 rated 85+ 14 Madden 2010: 7 rated 90+, 12 rated 85+ 7 Madden 2011: 7 rated 90+, 12 rated 85+ 7 Madden 2012: 8 rated 90+, 10 rated 85+ 8 Madden 2013: 2 rated 90+, 6 rated 85+ 2 Madden 2014: 3 rated 90+, 9 rated 85+ 3 Madden 2015: 2 rated 90+, 7 rated 85+ 2 Madden 2016: 4 rated 90+, 10 rated 85+ 4 Madden 2017: 1 rated 90+, 5 rated 85+ 1 Madden 2018: 1 rated 90+, 3 rated 85+ 1 Madden 2019: 0 rated 90+, 4 rated 85+ Madden 2020: 2 rated 90+, 6 rated 85+ 2 Madden 2021: 1 rated 90+, 8 rated 85+ 1 Madden 2022: 2 rated 90+, 4 rated 85+ 2 Madden 2023: 5 rated 90+, 7 rated 85+ 5 Madden 2024: 1 rated 90+, 6 rated 85+ 1 Madden 2025: 0 rated 90+, 6 rated 85+ Madden 2026: 1 rated 90+, 7 rated 85+ 1 Madden 2027: 4 rated 90+, 7 rated 85+ 4 '06'09'12'15'18'21'24'27
Players rated 90+ in each edition. Hover a bar for the 85+ count.

97+ overall

PlayerSeasons at 97+Span
Peyton Manning 72006–2012
Marvin Harrison 32006–2008
Dwight Freeney 32006–2011
Adam Vinatieri 22007–2008
Bob Sanders 12009–2009
Reggie Wayne 12009–2009

Season rosters (22 editions)